Brace for a Year of Volatility Ahead
Happy Monday Morning!
Back to our regularly scheduled programming after a few weeks off during the holidays. Last year was an eventful year across the Canadian Real Estate spectrum to say the least. I figured i’d start off the New Year with a quick sentiment check.
And the survey says… things are going to get worse. My poll on Twitter garnered nearly 5000 votes, with almost 80% of respondents calling for a further correction in prices by the end of 2023. Yes, it’s true Twitter tends to skew bearish, however it’s hard to deny that further downside is likely given the rapid surge in home prices suddenly colliding with the fastest rate hiking cycle most people have ever seen.
In fact, on a debt adjusted basis, this rate cycle is more than twice as severe as the 1980’s.
Prices have already dropped quite a bit. The national home price index is down 16% since it peaked in March 2022, that’s the steepest decline on record, dating back to 2005. While we are nearing the end of this rate hiking cycle, markets are still expecting more pain ahead from Tiff Macklem thanks to another strong labour report. The Canadian economy added 104,000 jobs in December, blowing past expectations of 5000 jobs. Ok there are a few things here that make you go hmmm.
We added more than 20X forecast. A large rounding error or very bad forecasting.
We added nearly half the jobs the US did, and our population is one tenth the size. Seems odd.
This conflicts with PMI and ISM data which was released the same day and has completely rolled over. All indexes point to a contraction in both goods and services.
Labour data is historically lagging and prone to revisions. Will the Bank of Canada look past this? Markets don’t seem to think so and are placing 73% odds of a 25bps rate hike at the January 25th meeting. That would bring the overnight rate to 4.5% and the prime rate to a whopping 6.7%. That would mean any borrower taking out a variable rate mortgage would be stress tested with an 8 in front of it. No bueno.
Again, making the case for lower prices is not hard. I do struggle being stuck alongside consensus. Typically when everyone is positioned one way, the opposite tends to happen. But there are not many bull cases to be made today.
The bull case is the tsunami of people migrating here. Canada added 431,645 new permanent residents in 2022, a record high. That topped the previous high in 2021 of 405,000 and the government isn’t satisfied yet. They are targeting 465,000 new permanent residents in 2023, 485,000 in 2024 and 500,000 in 2025. Keep in mind this doesn’t include foreign students or temporary workers. When you lump those people into the equation our population actually expanded by 865,000 over the past twelve months!!
In the near term, interest rates are going to continue to drag housing lower. However, a combination of massive immigration and a sudden pause in new housing construction due to economically unfeasible development suggests we’ll still be talking about a housing crisis five years from now.
Yes, brace for a year of volatility ahead, it will be a doozy.
Another point about property assessments. A friend who lives in a lower Vancouver Island municipality was told by a recently elected municipal councillor that their council is concerned about the 'black box' of how assessments are derived. Is it just BC Assessment who determine this and/or is the real estate industry (gasp!) involved?
We just received our property assessment. Curious if anyone has estimated the increased tax revenues the province has taken with their massive unilateral assessment increases over the past 2 years - when applied to the complete real estate picture. This has to be a MASSIVE number.
We have watched our assessed value go from 1.2M in 2021 to 1.6M in 2022 and now 1.8M in 2023 and I can guarantee you we would not be able to sell our home for the assessed value. Is the tax calculation being adjusted to soften the tax blow or still the same equation from 2021? As a new retiree, this indiscriminate taxation is causing me to seriously consider leaving the country because I have no mechanism to keep up with the level of taxation. We considered downsizing and moving into our basement suite and renting the main floor but my accountant advised that we would lose principle residence if we did this.